The health-system utilization forecasting conundrum: One size definitely doesn’t fit all.

Health system leaders are increasingly telling us they're not satisfied with their third-party vendor volume forecasts. Learn what's driving their challenge.

Eric Fontana
Eric Fontana
Updated Jul 7, 2026 7 min read

Recently we’ve been chatting with several health system strategy leaders who seem to be dealing with a similar problem: the forecasting products they license are polished and expensive but increasingly challenged to be useful at the local market level where real decisions are made. If one scans across the national-level estimates from the usual major health system forecasting providers, many of these forecasts are broadly fine. They capture the big trends, line up the conventional wisdom, and produce something that looks credible in a board pack. But a forecast can be both perfectly respectable in aggregate and completely whiff-it in a specific market depending on some of the ground-level forces at play. That can be a bit of a problem, if you’re using intel to help drive capital projects, service line expansion, physician recruitment, bed planning, ambulatory strategy, or trying to unpack where future demand is likely to land.

The challenge, as we are increasingly hearing from strategy and service line leaders, is straightforward. A fair number of third-party models lean heavily on national utilization rates and standardized assumptions about how care will shift over time. They appear to assume that market dynamics are similar enough from one region to the next that broad adjustment factors will do the job. But what seems to be emerging in our conversations is just how often this approach has been missing the mark in recent years. The worst examples find some trying to plan with forecasts that are directionally inconsistent with where their market has been trending.

Urban and rural markets behave differently. Regions with very different payer mixes behave differently. Affluent suburbs with strong preventive health uptake behave differently from poorer communities where people delay care, struggle with transport, and bounce in and out of coverage among many contributors to poorer overall health. Use rates vary by race, by socioeconomic status, by access, by local provider supply, and by how fractured the insurance picture has become. When you’re boots on the ground in those markets none of that stuff is marginal; it goes straight to the heart of your demand equation.

Let’s talk.

Questions? Want to learn more about what Union can do for you? We’d love to hear from you.