Consumerism has reshaped healthcare—just not how it was expected to

When I began my career in healthcare research over a decade ago, the concept of consumerism as a transformative force was in its heyday. 

Yulan Egan
Yulan Egan
Updated Jul 19, 2024 15 min read

When I began my career in healthcare research over a decade ago, the concept of consumerism as a transformative force was in its heyday. High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) were seeing explosive growth. Urgent care centers were cropping up on every corner and retailers such as CVS and Walgreens were entering the clinic space. Patient-facing transparency vendors (Castlight comes to mind) were attracting significant attention and investment. Rumors were swirling that corporate giants Walmart and Amazon might be poised to bring their consumer savvy to the healthcare space. At the time, skeptics pointed to the quirks of the healthcare industry that might hinder the transition to a more market-based model, but their voices were largely drowned out by those predicting sweeping change.

Why the general enthusiasm for the concept? Consumerism was touted as a politically neutral mechanism for solving two problems that were (and are) in many ways at odds with one another:

  1. Frustrations by patients with access to care. Patients wanted more options, were frustrated they weren’t getting them, and were increasingly vocal to their employers and elected officials.
  2. Steep increases in employer health costs in the early 2000s. The rate of cost growth has since slowed for a variety of reasons, mostly related to the state of the broader economy, but in the early 2000s it was not uncommon for employers to see annual cost growth of 10% or more.

Let’s talk.

Questions? Want to learn more about what Union can do for you? We’d love to hear from you.